If only the week had ended on Wednesday, as by that point, everything except Berkshire Hathaway was up substantially. Unfortunately, the Dubai debacle on Thanksgiving resulted in a marked decline come opening on Friday. There was some recovery by the end of the day, but it certainly wasn’t enough to regain all that was lost. Nonetheless, most portfolios did end the week slightly up from where they had been a week ago. Still, the gains could have been so much greater.

Due to some software difficulties, there will be no chart this week. However, I have good reason to suspect it will make a full return next week. Until then, you’ll have to make do with the table:

Portfolio Last Week This Week % Chg Total Gain CAGR
Precious Metals $1891.32 $1898.74 +0.39% +$398.74 +59.66%
Magic Formula $1804.40 $1833.99 +1.64% +$333.99 +33.92%
TMW $1816.20 $1816.20 0.00% +$316.20 +39.37%
Caribou $1780.11 $1791.73 +0.65% +$291.73 +29.70%
Decision Moose $1670.48 $1729.17 +3.51% +$229.17 +23.17%
Berkshire Hathaway $1708.26 $1676.05 -1.89% +$176.05 +11.99%

If there were a chart, it still wouldn’t show you much. We are at the point where even several percentage points of gain or loss don’t add up to much in overall movement. In any case, here are my thoughts on the week:

  • The precious metals remain at top. Until Friday’s slight decline, gold had been in the midst of nine consecutive up days, which made it very hard to beat. Silver hadn’t been quite as impressive, but the precious metals nevertheless ended the week slightly up.
  • Thanks to a relatively decent week, the Magic Formula has reclaimed second place after a brief time in third. The lead is not very impressive, so I wouldn’t count on it lasting in the short run. Even in the long run, I expect it to fall to third, behind Caribou and Decision Moose. Of course, we all know how useful my predictions are.
  • TMW ultimately didn’t go anywhere, falling right back to where it started the week. It’s good to know that even in a week that was neutral for the market as a whole, most of the portfolios made some gains.
  • Still invested in EWZ, Caribou managed to gain slightly on the week. Of course, the gain had been 3.69% on Wednesday, but Friday had other plans for the portfolio.
  • Inexplicably, Decision Moose somehow managed to keep its Wednesday position, though I’m skeptical. If you look at the chart for ILF, you’ll see a sudden spike immediately before close on Friday. There is an associated spike in trading volume, but it still seems strange to me that it happened to jump almost exactly to Wednesday’s close. All will be settled on Monday when the markets open, but for now I’m taking this with a grain of salt.
  • Rounding up this herd, we find Berkshire Hathaway, casually lounging around at the bottom. Of course, the CAGR is in the range of what I’d expect long-term for BRK-B, so it’s not like there’s any overwhelming underperformance here. The market as a whole has outperformed general expectations this year, but that hasn’t transferred over to Berkshire Hathaway. After a few years, it should manage to maintain a position above TMW and the precious metals, but probably not above anything else. Then again, Buffett’s eventual retirement could completely change that prediction.

Like so many weeks before, Caribou has once again elected to remain invested in EWZ, though it hasn’t really gone anywhere in the past few weeks. I see no reason to suspect this will change for at least another couple of weeks. That said, it’s sometimes hard to predict exactly what will happen without digging up the historical prices.

Anyway, here’s the MFI portfolio detail:

Stock Purchase Date Cost Last Week Current Dividends Gain
QLTI 2009-03-10 $1.44 $3.69 $4.82 $0.00 +234.72%
CTCM 2009-04-08 $5.80 $15.64 $14.68 $0.00 +153.10%
MSB 2009-03-10 $6.06 $11.82 $12.33 $0.60 +113.21%
HSII 2009-01-22 $16.79 $28.54 $28.50 $0.52 +72.89%
PRGX 2009-04-08 $3.25 $4.75 $4.61 $0.00 +41.85%
GHM 2009-06-11 $13.95 $18.86 $18.78 $0.02 +34.77%
VSNT 2009-05-07 $14.68 $17.98 $18.93 $0.00 +28.95%
ENDP 2009-06-11 $17.59 $22.20 $22.60 $0.00 +28.48%
PTIE 2009-03-10 $3.96 $4.75 $4.94 $0.00 +24.75%
KSW 2009-01-22 $2.95 $3.45 $3.49 $0.10 +21.69%
ELNK 2009-04-08 $7.08 $8.47 $8.10 $0.14 +21.69%
KHD 2009-01-22 $10.17 $11.58 $11.61 $0.00 +14.17%
TSRA 2009-11-04 $21.29 $23.66 $23.65 $0.00 +11.09%
LO 2009-09-09 $73.49 $79.48 $78.91 $0.00 +7.37%
SOLR 2009-07-10 $4.59 $4.74 $4.83 $0.00 +5.25%
CHKE 2009-05-07 $18.75 $19.13 $18.58 $1.00 +4.43%
UEPS 2009-11-04 $18.25 $18.92 $18.71 $0.00 +2.52%
CYTK 2009-09-09 $3.21 $3.40 $3.25 $0.00 +1.25%
DIVX 2009-07-10 $5.02 $5.21 $5.02 $0.00 0.00%
GNI 2009-08-05 $92.00 $89.23 $90.20 $1.80 0.00%
EME 2009-08-05 $24.30 $24.56 $23.96 $0.00 -1.38%
QCOR 2009-05-07 $4.44 $4.16 $4.28 $0.00 -3.67%
AMED 2009-11-04 $41.51 $37.69 $38.19 $0.00 -7.99%
MIPS 2009-10-07 $4.15 $3.88 $3.81 $0.00 -8.19%
JCOM 2009-10-07 $22.18 $20.40 $20.09 $0.00 -9.41%
GIGM 2009-10-07 $4.77 $4.09 $4.07 $0.00 -14.68%
PPD 2009-09-09 $47.50 $37.22 $39.02 $0.00 -17.85%
USMO 2009-08-05 $12.80 $10.37 $10.22 $0.00 -20.15%
MTXX 2009-07-10 $5.37 $4.22 $3.98 $0.00 -25.88%
SCMP 2009-06-11 $6.43 $3.71 $3.47 $0.00 -46.03%

QLTI climbed over a dollar to reclaim its ridiculous 200+% gain. That’s right, the initial $50 investment is currently worth $167.36. If only I’d had the foresight to invest my entire portfolio. Of course, that’d have been a pretty dumb move at the time, but it sure looks great in hindsight. A bunch of other stocks had good weeks, as well. A few other stocks had some terrible weeks, and SCMP is giving me no hope that it will ever make progress toward the green side of things. At least stocks have more upward-potential than downward: they can go as high as they want, but the most they can go down is to $0.

Disclaimer: This post is a description of my own forays into investing, and should not be construed as investment advice or the recommendation of any particular security over any other. Please consult your investment adviser or accountant before making any investment decisions. What’s right for me is very likely to not be right for you.

I know precious metals aren’t that interesting, but for the moment, they seem to be the assets with the largest wings. This is reflected in this week’s portfolio comparison, with both gold and silver doing superbly. The rest of the portfolios? Not so much. That’s not to say none of the others were up, because they were, but not by nearly as much. If you look at the market as a whole, things were even uglier. In short, every portfolio dropped relative to my precious metals baseline.

No changes have been made to the comparison this week. I suppose that at this point, there’s no point in even mentioning this completely expected and mundane factoid. On the off-chance I do make a change to the comparison, that would be noteworthy. Anyway, here’s this week’s data:

Portfolio Last Week This Week % Chg Total Gain CAGR
Precious Metals $1808.60 $1891.32 +4.57% +$391.32 +60.64%
TMW $1820.51 $1816.20 -2.37% +$316.20 +40.45%
Magic Formula $1794.05 $1804.40 +0.58% +$304.40 +32.21%
Caribou $1777.03 $1780.11 +0.17% +$280.11 +29.46%
Berkshire Hathaway $1690.42 $1708.26 +1.06% +$208.26 +14.89%
Decision Moose $1680.09 $1670.48 -0.57% +$170.48 +18.72%

You can see the precious metals portfolio just barely peeking up out of the morass of colorful lines on the right side of the chart. Everything else remains clustered in their two little groups, with the eventual victor remaining elusive for the moment.

  • As I stated above, the comparison has a new leader this week, and that’s the precious metals portfolio. Of course, since I use this portfolio as a proxy for inflation, this isn’t boding well for the other portfolios’ performances. However, even if the prices are rising in certain assets, I haven’t yet seen these price changes at the grocery store, for instance.
  • Next in line is TMW, which despite performing the worst of any portfolio this week, manages to fall only to second place. We’ll have to wait until next week to see if some kind of pattern is emerging.
  • The Magic Formula had a fairly positive week, if not completely impressive. You’ll see more in the MFI detail below, but while some stocks are turning completely atrocious, a few gems are keeping the boat afloat.
  • Berkshire Hathaway was actually the second best portfolio this week, climbing a little over 1%.
  • Caribou managed a slight gain, still invested in EWZ. Mind you, as with most portfolios this week, the gain was much more impressive on Wednesday. However, Thursday and Friday’s poor performances managed to erode almost all of the gains, leaving us with this rather paltry jump. I’ll take it, anyway.
  • Strangely, Decision Moose actually fell on the week, as ILF actually fell on the week. The difference from EWZ wasn’t spectacular, but when you’re this close to zero, the results can show up like this.

Caribou has elected to stick with EWZ for yet another week, despite the continued strength in the precious metals market. GLD is now the fourth-highest ranking asset, but it still has a long way to go if it wants to surpass EWZ as the top choice in the model.

Anyway, here’s the MFI portfolio detail:

Stock Purchase Date Cost Last Week Current Dividends Gain
CTCM 2009-04-08 $5.80 $16.78 $15.64 $0.00 +169.66%
QLTI 2009-03-10 $1.44 $3.82 $3.69 $0.00 +156.25%
MSB 2009-03-10 $6.06 $10.74 $11.82 $0.60 +104.80%
HSII 2009-01-22 $16.79 $28.38 $28.54 $0.52 +73.13%
PRGX 2009-04-08 $3.25 $4.62 $4.75 $0.00 +46.15%
GHM 2009-06-11 $13.95 $16.78 $18.86 $0.02 +35.34%
ENDP 2009-06-11 $17.59 $22.70 $22.20 $0.00 +26.21%
VSNT 2009-05-07 $14.68 $17.57 $17.98 $0.00 +22.48%
ELNK 2009-04-08 $7.08 $8.42 $8.47 $0.14 +21.70%
KSW 2009-01-22 $2.95 $3.33 $3.45 $0.10 +20.33%
PTIE 2009-03-10 $3.96 $4.91 $4.75 $0.00 +19.95%
KHD 2009-01-22 $10.17 $9.70 $11.58 $0.00 +13.88%
TSRA 2009-11-04 $21.29 $24.25 $23.66 $0.00 +11.14%
LO 2009-09-09 $73.49 $79.28 $79.48 $0.00 +8.15%
CHKE 2009-05-07 $18.75 $19.25 $19.13 $1.00 +7.36%
CYTK 2009-09-09 $3.21 $3.35 $3.40 $0.00 +5.92%
DIVX 2009-07-10 $5.02 $5.26 $5.21 $0.00 +3.78%
UEPS 2009-11-04 $18.25 $19.60 $18.92 $0.00 +3.67%
SOLR 2009-07-10 $4.59 $4.72 $4.74 $0.00 +3.28%
EME 2009-08-05 $24.30 $25.33 $24.56 $0.00 +1.09%
GNI 2009-08-05 $92.00 $90.12 $89.23 $1.80 -1.05%
QCOR 2009-05-07 $4.44 $3.50 $4.16 $0.00 -6.37%
MIPS 2009-10-07 $4.15 $4.01 $3.88 $0.00 -6.51%
JCOM 2009-10-07 $22.18 $20.77 $20.40 $0.00 -8.02%
AMED 2009-11-04 $41.51 $39.15 $37.69 $0.00 -9.20%
GIGM 2009-10-07 $4.77 $4.29 $4.09 $0.00 -14.26%
USMO 2009-08-05 $12.80 $10.62 $10.37 $0.00 -18.98%
MTXX 2009-07-10 $5.37 $3.79 $4.22 $0.00 -21.42%
PPD 2009-09-09 $47.50 $41.20 $37.22 $0.00 -21.64%
SCMP 2009-06-11 $6.43 $3.78 $3.71 $0.00 -42.30%

A couple of stocks received dividends this week: MSB and HSII. Of course, the dividends were actually from last month, but that’s how long they take to show up at the broker, I guess. A few more stocks are moving decidedly into the clunker range, which gives me some bad feelings about their futures. Luckily, a few gems at the top are keeping the ship sailing well above the water line. The monthly decisions that will start coming up in a couple of months will no doubt be interesting.

Disclaimer: This post is a description of my own forays into investing, and should not be construed as investment advice or the recommendation of any particular security over any other. Please consult your investment adviser or accountant before making any investment decisions. What’s right for me is very likely to not be right for you.

This last week in the stock market began with a bang, with most portfolios up significantly. However, it was little more than a coast after that, with everything except the precious metals portfolio finishing the week either even or lower than the initial close on Monday. In a sense, it was last weekend that was wonderful, with the week itself leaving everyone decidedly underwhelmed. Weeks like that are nothing new, however, and I could have no doubt simply copied an introductory paragraph from a previous post. In fact, how do you know I didn’t do just that? (Okay, okay, I’m not quite that evil. Yet.)

My writing mojo seems to be missing at the moment, so let’s look at this week’s data and hopefully I’ll have something more impressive to say by the time we reach the flip side:

Portfolio Last Week This Week % Chg Total Gain CAGR
TMW $1780.40 $1820.51 +2.25% +$320.51 +41.99%
Precious Metals $1789.55 $1808.60 +1.06% +$308.60 +53.73%
Magic Formula $1792.67 $1794.05 +0.08% +$294.05 +32.14%
Caribou $1763.52 $1777.03 +0.77% +$277.03 +29.97%
Berkshire Hathaway $1697.36 $1690.42 -0.41% +$190.42 +13.79%
Decision Moose $1687.55 $1680.09 -0.44% +$180.09 +20.05%

Portfolio Comparison: 2009-11-13

Despite my best efforts to make the chart readable, it remains somewhat difficult to distinguish the various portfolios. What is obvious, however, is that the Magic Formula portfolio has had its once commanding lead entirely decimated and that there is currently a tight race for first place. There are a couple of stragglers even lower on the chart, but I guess not everyone can compete for the gold. Here’s my summary of this week’s movements:

  • Unless my selective memory is working in full force, it has been a long time since a portfolio other than the Magic Formula has finished a week in first place. At the moment, however, nothing manages to beat the market as a whole, with the TMW portfolio taking its place at the top. Mind you, I still believe it’s possible for some people to reliably and consistently beat the market over time, but it’s not happening here for the moment.
  • Heck, just planting your money in the precious metals hasn’t been a bad option so far this year. The precious metals portfolio was the only one to actually gain during the week this week, and with gold reaching a new high of $1118.50, the prospects look bright here, indeed. Of course, some may be wondering if a bubble is forming. It could be possible, but one analyst suggested this isn’t likely to happen until silver reaches $20, at which point we might see a small bubble and its associated correction. Of course, take Mr. Random Analyst’s musings with a grain of salt.
  • Finally, we see the Magic Formula portfolio in third, barely managing a gain for the week at all. Despite strength in the overall market, some MFI stocks have been taking a beating, but more on that later.
  • Caribou was also barely up, after being significantly up on Monday’s close. After Monday, the Brazilian markets fell throughout most of the week, until Friday, when they regained some of what they’d lost.
  • Berkshire Hathaway didn’t end up doing much at all, which isn’t anything new for this stock. However, it has held onto the gains it managed a week or two ago.
  • Finally, Decision Moose signaled a switch back into ILF, which unfortunately was executed after the weekend burst. You’ll note that all of these recent signals have been weak buys or sells, so a more savvy investor might have held off. However, I’m not quite that brilliant, and stick with the very mechanical method of executing the trade on Tuesday, no questions asked. It didn’t help this week.

Caribou will be holding EWZ for at least another week. The scores suggest this may continue for another few weeks, with other assets looking downright pathetic by comparison. Of course, scores can change relatively rapidly, so we’ll just have to see what happens in the coming weeks.

Anyway, here’s the MFI portfolio detail:

Stock Purchase Date Cost Last Week Current Dividends Gain
CTCM 2009-04-08 $5.80 $16.55 $16.78 $0.00 +189.31%
QLTI 2009-03-10 $1.44 $3.62 $3.82 $0.00 +165.28%
MSB 2009-03-10 $6.06 $10.16 $10.74 $0.38 +83.37%
HSII 2009-01-22 $16.79 $26.99 $28.38 $0.39 +71.40%
PRGX 2009-04-08 $3.25 $5.26 $4.62 $0.00 +42.15%
ENDP 2009-06-11 $17.59 $23.00 $22.70 $0.00 +29.05%
PTIE 2009-03-10 $3.96 $4.97 $4.91 $0.00 +23.99%
ELNK 2009-04-08 $7.08 $8.30 $8.42 $0.14 +20.99%
GHM 2009-06-11 $13.95 $16.70 $16.78 $0.02 +20.43%
VSNT 2009-05-07 $14.68 $18.15 $17.57 $0.00 +19.69%
KSW 2009-01-22 $2.95 $3.40 $3.33 $0.10 +16.26%
TSRA 2009-11-04 $21.29 $22.09 $24.25 $0.00 +13.91%
CHKE 2009-05-07 $18.75 $18.68 $19.25 $1.00 +8.00%
LO 2009-09-09 $73.49 $77.65 $79.28 $0.00 +7.88%
UEPS 2009-11-04 $18.25 $19.35 $19.60 $0.00 +7.39%
DIVX 2009-07-10 $5.02 $5.25 $5.26 $0.00 +4.78%
CYTK 2009-09-09 $3.21 $3.27 $3.35 $0.00 +4.36%
EME 2009-08-05 $24.30 $24.65 $25.33 $0.00 +4.26%
SOLR 2009-07-10 $4.59 $5.24 $4.72 $0.00 +2.85%
GNI 2009-08-05 $92.00 $90.40 $90.12 $1.80 -0.09%
MIPS 2009-10-07 $4.15 $4.10 $4.01 $0.00 -3.37%
KHD 2009-01-22 $10.17 $9.40 $9.70 $0.00 -4.61%
AMED 2009-11-04 $41.51 $39.96 $39.15 $0.00 -5.68%
JCOM 2009-10-07 $22.18 $21.82 $20.77 $0.00 -6.35%
GIGM 2009-10-07 $4.77 $3.79 $4.29 $0.00 -10.06%
PPD 2009-09-09 $47.50 $41.21 $41.20 $0.00 -13.26%
USMO 2009-08-05 $12.80 $10.80 $10.62 $0.00 -17.03%
QCOR 2009-05-07 $4.44 $3.94 $3.50 $0.00 -21.23%
MTXX 2009-07-10 $5.37 $4.14 $3.79 $0.00 -29.42%
SCMP 2009-06-11 $6.43 $4.14 $3.78 $0.00 -41.21%

Most MFI stocks are doing either decently or fantastic. However, there are a few stocks down at the bottom that concern me. SCMP is demonstrating just how useless it is at the moment, continuing to decline into oblivion. My only solace here is that it still has 7 months or so to get with the program. A number of other stocks are also down, but most of them are more recent purchases, with most of the early purchases well into the green. A strong run in the markets anytime in the next few months could turn around the fortunes of these stocks quickly. It would probably be a lot less heart-wrenching to buy the stock, and then ignore it until it comes time to sell. Alas, I don’t think I could do that.

Disclaimer: This post is a description of my own forays into investing, and should not be construed as investment advice or the recommendation of any particular security over any other. Please consult your investment adviser or accountant before making any investment decisions. What’s right for me is very likely to not be right for you.

Any week in which all the portfolios go up can be considered a good week, as far as I’m concerned. This was undoubtedly the result this week, with each of the portfolios ultimately climbing. The range of performance was wide, of course, ranging from just below 1% to nearly 8%, so the portfolios were definitely not all equal. However, they were nonetheless all in the black (or green) leaving most investors happy as clams. After the debacle that was last week, this is welcome news indeed.

As I mentioned last week, $150 was added to each of the portfolios this week, bringing the baseline up to $1500. Only two months remain before the base will be fixed at $1800 (invested over the course of a year). At that point, the portfolios will live or die on their own merits. Let’s look at the performance this week:

Portfolio Last Week This Week % Chg Total Gain CAGR
Magic Formula $1621.30 $1792.67 +1.17% +$292.67 +32.91%
Precious Metals $1548.44 $1789.55 +5.78% +$289.55 +53.27%
TMW $1576.85 $1780.40 +3.18% +$280.40 +39.23%
Caribou $1490.49 $1763.52 +7.80% +$263.52 +29.55%
Berkshire Hathaway $1483.46 $1697.36 +4.03% +$197.36 +14.74%
Decision Moose $1524.92 $1687.55 +0.83% +$187.55 +21.26%

I definitely am enjoying the green of this table much more than I did the red of last week’s table.

Portfolio Comparison: 2009-11-06

I made good on my threat and made the lines thinner in the chart this week. It doesn’t necessarily make it any easier to discern any particular detail, but I think you have a slightly better chance of being able to separate the different portfolios, especially when they are very close to each other, as they are now. I’ll try to break things down somewhat:

  • In a briefly shocking moment on Wednesday, the Magic Formula portfolio was no longer in first place, having been surpassed by TMW. By Friday, it managed to rebound, but it’s clear that MFI no longer has the commanding lead it had just a few short weeks ago. The portfolio was one of the more mild ones this week, only gaining just over 1%.
  • As you might have inferred from TMW’s brief lead, the week in the market as a whole was not a terrible one, showing small but steady gains each day of the week. This performance was reflected as well in Berkshire Hathaway’s results, which finally showed a glimmer of a trend beyond that of neutrality.
  • The precious metals did quite well this week, suggesting investors are continuing to invest in real assets rather than cash, but also warning of either a bubble or inflation. Either way, I like to use the precious metals as a benchmark.
  • The big winner, however, this week was definitely the Caribou portfolio, which continued to rocket upward on the back of Brazil and the EWZ ETF. The race near the top is very close, and if EWZ continues to do well, Caribou has a very real chance of taking the lead.
  • Finally, Decision Moose interpreted last week’s debacle as a short-term sell signal and moved into cash, leading to mediocre gains, relatively speaking.

As I hinted above, Caribou will be remaining with EWZ for yet another week. Most assets’ scores have been declining recently, though EWZ continues to command a strong lead. The next-best asset, ILF, isn’t even close for the moment.

Anyway, here’s the MFI portfolio detail:

Stock Purchase Date Cost Last Week Current Dividends Gain
CTCM 2009-04-08 $5.80 $16.08 $16.55 $0.00 +185.34%
QLTI 2009-03-10 $1.44 $3.49 $3.62 $0.00 +151.39%
MSB 2009-03-10 $6.06 $10.00 $10.16 $0.38 +73.80%
HSII 2009-01-22 $16.79 $27.36 $26.99 $0.39 +63.12%
PRGX 2009-04-08 $3.25 $5.18 $5.26 $0.00 +61.85%
ENDP 2009-06-11 $17.59 $22.40 $23.00 $0.00 +30.76%
PTIE 2009-03-10 $3.96 $5.07 $4.97 $0.00 +25.51%
VSNT 2009-05-07 $14.68 $18.44 $18.15 $0.00 +23.64%
GHM 2009-06-11 $13.95 $14.17 $16.70 $0.02 +19.86%
ELNK 2009-04-08 $7.08 $8.10 $8.30 $0.14 +19.29%
KSW 2009-01-22 $2.95 $3.44 $3.40 $0.10 +18.64%
SOLR 2009-07-10 $4.59 $5.25 $5.24 $0.00 +14.18%
UEPS 2009-11-04 $18.25 N/A $19.35 $0.00 +6.03%
LO 2009-09-09 $73.49 $77.72 $77.65 $0.00 +5.66%
CHKE 2009-05-07 $18.75 $18.93 $18.68 $1.00 +4.96%
DIVX 2009-07-10 $5.02 $4.81 $5.25 $0.00 +4.58%
TSRA 2009-11-04 $21.29 N/A $22.09 $0.00 +3.76%
CYTK 2009-09-09 $3.21 $3.19 $3.27 $0.00 +1.87%
EME 2009-08-05 $24.30 $23.62 $24.65 $0.00 +1.46%
GNI 2009-08-05 $92.00 $91.00 $90.40 $1.80 +0.22%
MIPS 2009-10-07 $4.15 $3.95 $4.10 $0.00 -1.20%
JCOM 2009-10-07 $22.18 $20.45 $21.82 $0.00 -1.61%
AMED 2009-11-04 $41.51 N/A $39.96 $0.00 -3.73%
KHD 2009-01-22 $10.17 $9.16 $9.40 $0.00 -7.56%
QCOR 2009-05-07 $4.44 $4.54 $3.94 $0.00 -11.33%
PPD 2009-09-09 $47.50 $39.54 $41.21 $0.00 -13.23%
USMO 2009-08-05 $12.80 $10.90 $10.80 $0.00 -15.62%
GIGM 2009-10-07 $4.77 $4.09 $3.79 $0.00 -20.55%
MTXX 2009-07-10 $5.37 $4.50 $4.14 $0.00 -22.91%
SCMP 2009-06-11 $6.43 $4.37 $4.14 $0.00 -35.61%

Overall, I don’t feel too bad about this week, though I’d like to see stronger performances. Small cap stocks really do seem to behave differently from their large cap brethren, and it’s interesting to watch how the two classes are affected differently in different market conditions. For now, there seems to be a weakness in small caps, though I hope that discontinues, as it would benefit this portfolio greatly.

Disclaimer: This post is a description of my own forays into investing, and should not be construed as investment advice or the recommendation of any particular security over any other. Please consult your investment adviser or accountant before making any investment decisions. What’s right for me is very likely to not be right for you.

Another month has come and gone, which means it’s time for yet another round of Magic Formula stock purchases. This is the monumental tenth time I have gone through this process, which leaves only two more to go before it’ll be time to begin evaluating whether or not to keep the oldest stocks in the portfolio. I’ll cross that bridge when I come it. For the uninitiated, my methodology remains the same: pull the current list of top 30 stocks with a market capitalization of at least $50 million from the Magic Formula website, rank the list according to my own recreation of the formula, and then pick the top three that I don’t already own.

Needless to say, with a portfolio of eighteen stocks, I find that I have to move a bit down the list before I find ones I don’t currently own. In any case, here are my selections for this month:

Net1 UEPS Technologies, Inc. (UEPS)

  • Price: $17.78
  • Market Cap: $806.821M
  • Enterprise Value: $617.806M
  • Earnings Yield: 15.234%
  • Return on Invested Capital: 945.974%

The early trend in this MFI stock journey was biomedical companies, especially pharmaceuticals. Lately, however, another trend has emerged: technology. UEPS is actually rather interesting, in that they provide an alternative payment system for customers in South Africa. This is certainly an interesting selection, and I’m not sure exactly what to make of it. From a technical standpoint, the stock is rather unimpressive. Trading within a split-adjusted range of $10 to $30 for most of its history, it’s hard to make heads or tails of anything. There is a slight growth trend over the last year, so that could be promising. However, there does not appear to be a dividend.

Tessera Technologies, Inc. (TSRA)

  • Price: $21.20
  • Market Cap: $1,050.799M
  • Enterprise Value: $684.586M
  • Earnings Yield: 17.285%
  • Return on Invested Capital: 278.887%

Lo and behold, another technology company. TSRA develops miniaturization solutions for electronics manufacturers, which seems to be something to do with designing or helping clients to design semiconductor chips for whatever products they’re producing. It’s probably not a dying business just yet. TSRA’s stock price dropped significantly in early 2008, though they’ve shown some growth in 2009. Yet again, this company does not appear to pay a dividend, which seems to be a common occurrence for MFI stocks. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but merely my own commentary.

Amedisys Inc. (AMED)

  • Price: $41.25
  • Market Cap: $1,153.515M
  • Enterprise Value: $1,364.630M
  • Earnings Yield: 15.694%
  • Return on Invested Capital: 246.112%

Ah, back to the old stomping grounds, sort of. AMED isn’t a pharmaceutical company, but as their name indicates, they are definitely in the medical field. AMED provides hospice-type services to various individuals. This seems to include nursing, physical therapy, and so on. From a technical standpoint, they have shown a strong trend of growth since 2004, though they did suffer significantly during 2008. Like many stocks, this one also seems to pay no dividend.

These new stocks should be added to the Magic Formula portfolio sometime tomorrow. At approximately the same time, I will add $150 of new investment to each of the other virtual portfolios.

Disclaimer: This post is a description of my own forays into investing, and should not be construed as investment advice or the recommendation of any particular security over any other. Please consult your investment adviser or accountant before making any investment decisions. What’s right for me is very likely to not be right for you.

You know, it was bad enough when the market (and especially EWZ) plummeted on Wednesday this week. No, that simply wasn’t enough for the great investing gods. On Thursday, the market rocketed upward once again, regaining almost all of the value that had been lost on Wednesday. Unfortunately, this was nothing more than a fake out, as the market once again decided down was the “in” direction, resulting in every portfolio ultimately declining this week. It was a great week to be out of the markets. Unfortunately, my ability to send messages back in time is extraordinarily non-existent.

However, I won’t be at all surprised if the market once again moves upward come Monday. At this point, I kind of hope it hangs around a bit lower for a few days, so that the upcoming $150 investment in each of the virtual portfolios will result in more shares. The only thing I really don’t want is a bear market. Anyway, it may be exceedingly painful, but let’s look at this week’s numbers:

Portfolio Last Week This Week % Chg Total Gain CAGR
Magic Formula $1760.96 $1621.30 -7.93% +$271.30 +31.84%
TMW $1647.69 $1576.85 -4.30% +$226.85 +34.80%
Precious Metals $1619.49 $1548.44 -4.39% +$198.44 +44.04%
Decision Moose $1648.13 $1524.92 -7.48% +$174.92 +20.54%
Caribou $1609.81 $1490.49 -7.41% +$140.49 +18.29%
Berkshire Hathaway $1499.27 $1483.46 -1.05% +$133.46 +9.38%

I know, I know. Pick yourself up off the floor. The world hasn’t come to an end just yet.

Portfolio Comparison: 2009-10-30

The chart is becoming awfully clustered as we look to the right side. These nearly vertical lines make things difficult to discern. I will consider reducing the lines in width for next week, as it will probably slightly increase our ability to interpret the chart. Here are some short thoughts about each of the portfolios:

  • The only portfolio that didn’t suffer terribly was (perhaps not surprisingly) the Berkshire Hathaway portfolio, which continues its trend of being very neutral, neither moving too far up nor too far down. Weeks like this, it’s hard to complain. I still don’t personally own any BRK-B, but it’s something I’m thinking about.
  • Precious metals didn’t have a brilliant week, but that does tell us something about the nature of the decline. It appears to be either a flight into cash or perhaps signs of deflation finally affecting the markets. Now, I’m not sure if the total money supply is experiencing inflation or deflation at the moment, but it’s somewhat fun trying to speculate. Either way, with precious metals down so much, I have a hard time feeling too bad about the rest of the market.
  • Speaking of the rest of the market, TMW didn’t do too poorly, all things considered. It’s in the same ball park as the precious metals, which causes a nice flat line in the version of the chart that uses the precious metals index as its basis instead of the U.S. dollar. At some point, I should make that chart available.
  • Down at the bottom of the well this week is all three of my favored portfolios. The Magic Formula suffered a tough week, as investors seemed more prone to escape out of small cap companies. Decision Moose and Caribou both suffered as investors also seemed keen to get out of foreign markets. (Other foreign-investing ETFs showed similar losses in the 7% range.) Why U.S. stocks should be strong relative to non-U.S. stocks, I have no idea, with much of what I read suggesting other countries are in better economic shape.

Despite EWZ and its atrocious performance this week, the associated Caribou signal is still up approximately 5%. Caribou will be sticking it out with EWZ for at least another week, with nothing else particularly close in scoring. (The closest alternatives are Decision Moose’s pick, ILF, and our old friend EPP.)

Anyway, here’s the MFI portfolio detail:

Stock Purchase Date Cost Last Week Current Dividends Gain
CTCM 2009-04-08 $5.80 $18.77 $16.08 $0.00 +177.24%
QLTI 2009-03-10 $1.44 $3.47 $3.49 $0.00 +142.36%
MSB 2009-03-10 $6.06 $10.83 $10.00 $0.38 +71.16%
HSII 2009-01-22 $16.79 $25.27 $27.36 $0.39 +65.33%
PRGX 2009-04-08 $3.25 $6.65 $5.18 $0.00 +59.38%
PTIE 2009-03-10 $3.96 $5.51 $5.07 $0.00 +28.03%
ENDP 2009-06-11 $17.59 $23.22 $22.40 $0.00 +27.35%
VSNT 2009-05-07 $14.68 $19.37 $18.44 $0.00 +25.61%
KSW 2009-01-22 $2.95 $3.75 $3.44 $0.10 +19.99%
ELNK 2009-04-08 $7.08 $8.67 $8.10 $0.14 +16.47%
SOLR 2009-07-10 $4.59 $5.57 $5.25 $0.00 +14.40%
CHKE 2009-05-07 $18.75 $20.97 $18.93 $1.00 +6.29%
LO 2009-09-09 $73.49 $79.68 $77.72 $0.00 +5.76%
QCOR 2009-05-07 $4.44 $5.15 $4.54 $0.00 +2.18%
GHM 2009-06-11 $13.95 $16.24 $14.17 $0.02 +1.72%
GNI 2009-08-05 $92.00 $94.46 $91.00 $1.80 +0.87%
CYTK 2009-09-09 $3.21 $4.60 $3.19 $0.00 -0.62%
EME 2009-08-05 $24.30 $23.95 $23.62 $0.00 -2.78%
DIVX 2009-07-10 $5.02 $5.10 $4.81 $0.00 -4.18%
MIPS 2009-10-07 $4.15 $3.79 $3.95 $0.00 -4.82%
JCOM 2009-10-07 $22.18 $21.65 $20.45 $0.00 -7.79%
KHD 2009-01-22 $10.17 $10.45 $9.16 $0.00 -9.92%
GIGM 2009-10-07 $4.77 $4.66 $4.09 $0.00 -14.26%
USMO 2009-08-05 $12.80 $12.92 $10.90 $0.00 -14.84%
MTXX 2009-07-10 $5.37 $5.20 $4.50 $0.00 -16.20%
PPD 2009-09-09 $47.50 $41.68 $39.54 $0.00 -16.75%
SCMP 2009-06-11 $6.43 $5.10 $4.37 $0.00 -32.04%

It was an ugly week in MFI land. The few stocks that were up usually weren’t up by very much, with HSII proving to be a notable exception. The general trend was definitely to go down, down, and down some more. I can only hope the results are better next week.

Disclaimer: This post is a description of my own forays into investing, and should not be construed as investment advice or the recommendation of any particular security over any other. Please consult your investment adviser or accountant before making any investment decisions. What’s right for me is very likely to not be right for you.

Ah, the continuing saga of “What to Title These Posts” continues. I suppose at some point, I’m going to completely exhaust all of my creativity and will instead opt to name them something simple and succinct such as “Portfolio Comparison: Week of 2009-10-23″. In fact, that probably provides more information to the tentative potential reader. My opening paragraphs sure aren’t helping matters. I should be opening these posts with bold and simple descriptions of the week’s events: “Three portfolios fall as investors hesitate.” Actually, that sounds closer to a newspaper title than an opening paragraph…

All that aside, as you might have guessed, three portfolios were in fact down this week. There wasn’t necessarily any particular reason to this rhyme. Stocks were down on a grander scale, but some portfolios were able to make the best of a mediocre situation, such as my Decision Moose portfolio. Before I get to the details, however, let’s start with the week’s data:

Portfolio Last Week This Week % Chg Total Gain CAGR
Magic Formula $1816.44 $1760.96 -3.05% +$410.96 +48.18%
Decision Moose $1609.88 $1648.13 +2.38% +$298.13 +34.28%
TMW $1660.78 $1647.69 -0.79% +$297.69 +43.99%
Precious Metals $1606.62 $1619.49 +0.08% +$269.49 +54.31%
Caribou $1634.71 $1609.81 -1.52% +$259.81 +31.59%
Berkshire Hathaway $1493.85 $1499.27 +0.36% +$149.27 +11.18%

Portfolio Comparison: 2009-10-23

Basically, this week consisted of that drop you see at the end of the graph. Not everything was entirely bad, however, as I’ll expound on in this week’s detail:

  • At the bottom of the barrel this week, we find the Magic Formula portfolio, a rare tenant in this position indeed. Given the small market capitalization of most of the stocks in this portfolio, it suggests to me that investors were retreating somewhat to perceived safer investments. Even so, this portfolio has such a lead that a decline means very little in comparison to the others.
  • Meanwhile, the precious metals had a very neutral week. In fact, both gold and silver were slightly up.
  • Turning our attention back to stocks, we see that TMW, my proxy for the market as a whole, did fall a bit, but not nearly as much as the Magic Formula portfolio did. Meanwhile, Berkshire Hathaway was slightly up. The long-term trend in BRK-B is still one of neutrality, however, as it continues to languish in last place.
  • The Caribou portfolio, invested in EWZ (which tracks a Brazilian index), suffered a rather unfortunate loss. You see, early in the week, the Brazilian government announced that it would be levying a tax on foreign investment. I didn’t look into it much deeper to determine exactly what “foreign investment” means (be it investment by Brazilians in foreign markets or investment from abroad in Brazilian companies), but the result was the same regardless: At one point on the day, EWZ was down over 6%. By the end of the day, it managed to claw its way to only being down 3% or so, but the damage was done. Essentially, investors have repriced EWZ to be in line with the expected loss from the new tax.
  • Meanwhile, Decision Moose signaled a switch into ILF, a fund which tracks Latin American stocks, which is therefore heavily weighted in Brazil. I executed this switch Tuesday, <em>after</em> the news about the tax, but before the late-day gains. As a result, this portfolio managed to gain handsomely on the week. Sometimes, timing is everything.

Despite the new information about EWZ, Caribou has no plans to change course for the moment, choosing to once again stay with EWZ, at least for another week. Looking at the scoring, there is no immediate rising threat. ILF and EPP remain the other top assets. (Given that Caribou tracks money flow between assets, keeping two obviously correlated ETFs such as EWZ and ILF seems kind of silly, but I randomly made that choice months ago, and I really have no desire to randomly change it now.)

Anyway, here’s the MFI portfolio detail:

Stock Purchase Date Cost Last Week Current Dividends Gain
CTCM 2009-04-08 $5.80 $17.44 $18.77 $0.00 +223.62%
QLTI 2009-03-10 $1.44 $3.98 $3.47 $0.00 +140.97%
PRGX 2009-04-08 $3.25 $6.59 $6.65 $0.00 +104.62%
MSB 2009-03-10 $6.06 $10.95 $10.83 $0.38 +84.85%
HSII 2009-01-22 $16.79 $25.38 $25.27 $0.39 +52.87%
CYTK 2009-09-09 $3.21 $5.13 $4.60 $0.00 +43.30%
PTIE 2009-03-10 $3.96 $5.78 $5.51 $0.00 +39.14%
ENDP 2009-06-11 $17.59 $23.47 $23.22 $0.00 +32.01%
VSNT 2009-05-07 $14.68 $19.12 $19.37 $0.00 +31.95%
KSW 2009-01-22 $2.95 $3.70 $3.75 $0.10 +30.50%
ELNK 2009-04-08 $7.08 $8.55 $8.67 $0.14 +24.52%
SOLR 2009-07-10 $4.59 $5.51 $5.57 $0.00 +21.37%
CHKE 2009-05-07 $18.75 $22.08 $20.97 $1.00 +17.17%
GHM 2009-06-11 $13.95 $17.71 $16.24 $0.02 +16.56%
QCOR 2009-05-07 $4.44 $5.43 $5.15 $0.00 +15.91%
LO 2009-09-09 $73.49 $80.52 $79.68 $0.00 +8.42%
KHD 2009-01-22 $10.17 $10.96 $10.45 $0.00 +2.77%
GNI 2009-08-05 $92.00 $94.00 $94.46 $0.00 +2.67%
DIVX 2009-07-10 $5.02 $5.13 $5.10 $0.00 +1.59%
USMO 2009-08-05 $12.80 $13.10 $12.92 $0.00 +0.94%
EME 2009-08-05 $24.30 $25.13 $23.95 $0.00 -1.42%
GIGM 2009-10-07 $4.77 $4.87 $4.66 $0.00 -2.31%
JCOM 2009-10-07 $22.18 $22.08 $21.65 $0.00 -2.38%
MTXX 2009-07-10 $5.37 $5.56 $5.20 $0.00 -3.17%
MIPS 2009-10-07 $4.15 $4.08 $3.79 $0.00 -8.67%
PPD 2009-09-09 $47.50 $40.94 $41.68 $0.00 -12.25%
SCMP 2009-06-11 $6.43 $5.03 $5.10 $0.00 -20.68%

With a portfolio of this size, the same description can almost be used every week: some stocks were up, and others were down. The actual order from top to bottom barely changed this week, with only a couple of real movers. I borrowed the previous two sentences from last week’s post. Heck, they were even applicable! Keeping track of all these stocks in my head is somewhat difficult. While updating the data, I did notice that PPD has made some progress in a return to parity, but it still has a long way to go.

Disclaimer: This post is a description of my own forays into investing, and should not be construed as investment advice or the recommendation of any particular security over any other. Please consult your investment adviser or accountant before making any investment decisions. What’s right for me is very likely to not be right for you.

I think I need to take a class in writing appropriate titles or something. Well, either that, or I should defer the titling of the post until after I’ve written it. Some of these recent titles just don’t seem to sound as good a day later as they must have when I originally wrote them. In any case, as you may be able to infer from the title, the market was largely up, but a lot of gains were ultimately left on the table after a sobering performance on Friday. Of course, not every portfolio was basking in the green light of capital gains, as the precious metals portfolio did decline slightly.

Now that I’ve attempted to summarize the week in a single, succinct paragraph, I shall instead let the data speak for itself:

Portfolio Last Week This Week % Chg Total Gain CAGR
Magic Formula $1788.36 $1816.44 +1.57% +$466.44 +56.17%
TMW $1638.76 $1660.78 +1.34% +$310.78 +46.95%
Caribou $1561.73 $1634.71 +4.67% +$284.71 +35.34%
Decision Moose $1580.26 $1609.88 +1.87% +$259.88 +31.06%
Precious Metals $1617.01 $1606.62 -0.64% +$256.62 +54.38%
Berkshire Hathaway $1485.26 $1493.85 +0.58% +$143.85 +10.94%

Portfolio Comparison: 2009-10-16

You can easily see the recent trends. Of course, in this recent bull market, none of this is unexpected at all. The portfolios will be much more interesting to watch in the event of a return to bear conditions. That said, I’m not particularly hoping for such an occurrence, despite the additional material for analyzing it would give me. Let’s look at the various portfolios in slightly more detail:

  • We may as well do something different and start off with the only loser for the week: the precious metals. It wasn’t even a unanimous decision, as gold was slightly up. However, silver was down enough to counterbalance gold’s gains, and the portfolio ultimately ended up in decline. It wasn’t incredibly significant, however, so current holders of precious metals (myself included) shouldn’t be feeling too ill.
  • Another lackluster competitor this week was Berkshire Hathaway, which seems to be having trouble getting anything significant going.
  • Nonetheless, the market as a whole did reasonably well, with TMW, the Magic Formula, and even Decision Moose pocketing gains between 1 and 2%. Again, the gains would have been better were it not for Friday’s losses.
  • Although I seem to use the phrase “big winner” entirely too much, it is only appropriate to describe the Caribou portfolio as such this week, with it ultimately taking home a nearly 5% gain. Currently holding EWZ, we can see that stocks in Brazil have been performing very well in recent weeks. My only concern is for a sudden reversal. I’m not sure I’d call Brazil an emerging market, but I’m sure a lot of the capital invested there is from foreign sources. If the more established markets have a tough week, it could be even worse for EWZ as investors retreat to cash or bonds.

Despite my worries, the Caribou model itself isn’t showing a hint of concern, opting to continue holding EWZ for yet another week. This trade is only three weeks old, but the gain has been over 15% since then. If this continues much longer, a profit latch may trigger. I’m not entirely sure I’m sold on the methodological soundness of this tactic. Sure, if the previously held asset subsequently goes down, you look like a genius. If it continues up, however, you miss out on even more gains. It’s a balancing act, to be sure.

Finally, here’s the MFI portfolio detail:

Stock Purchase Date Cost Last Week Current Dividends Gain
CTCM 2009-04-08 $5.80 $17.60 $17.44 $0.00 +200.69%
QLTI 2009-03-10 $1.44 $3.81 $3.98 $0.00 +176.39%
PRGX 2009-04-08 $3.25 $5.99 $6.59 $0.00 +102.77%
MSB 2009-03-10 $6.06 $10.18 $10.95 $0.38 +86.83%
CYTK 2009-09-09 $3.21 $5.10 $5.13 $0.00 +59.81%
HSII 2009-01-22 $16.79 $23.80 $25.38 $0.39 +53.53%
PTIE 2009-03-10 $3.96 $5.55 $5.78 $0.00 +45.96%
ENDP 2009-06-11 $17.59 $23.82 $23.47 $0.00 +33.43%
VSNT 2009-05-07 $14.68 $18.83 $19.12 $0.00 +30.25%
KSW 2009-01-22 $2.95 $3.79 $3.70 $0.10 +28.80%
GHM 2009-06-11 $13.95 $16.00 $17.71 $0.02 +27.10%
CHKE 2009-05-07 $18.75 $22.70 $22.08 $1.00 +23.09%
ELNK 2009-04-08 $7.08 $8.69 $8.55 $0.14 +22.83%
QCOR 2009-05-07 $4.44 $5.58 $5.43 $0.00 +22.21%
SOLR 2009-07-10 $4.59 $5.71 $5.51 $0.00 +20.06%
LO 2009-09-09 $73.49 $77.79 $80.52 $0.00 +9.57%
KHD 2009-01-22 $10.17 $10.25 $10.96 $0.00 +7.78%
MTXX 2009-07-10 $5.37 $5.66 $5.56 $0.00 +3.54%
EME 2009-08-05 $24.30 $24.88 $25.13 $0.00 +3.44%
USMO 2009-08-05 $12.80 $13.20 $13.10 $0.00 +2.35%
DIVX 2009-07-10 $5.02 $5.27 $5.13 $0.00 +2.19%
GNI 2009-08-05 $92.00 $90.26 $94.00 $0.00 +2.17%
GIGM 2009-10-07 $4.77 $4.84 $4.87 $0.00 +2.10%
JCOM 2009-10-07 $22.18 $22.02 $22.08 $0.00 -0.44%
MIPS 2009-10-07 $4.15 $4.09 $4.08 $0.00 -1.69%
PPD 2009-09-09 $47.50 $42.09 $40.94 $0.00 -13.80%
SCMP 2009-06-11 $6.43 $5.27 $5.03 $0.00 -21.77%

With a portfolio of this size, the same description can almost be used every week: some stocks were up, and others were down. The actual order from top to bottom barely changed this week, with only a couple of real movers. Meanwhile, I’ve been considering the possibility of a different MFI methodology. You could simply hold the so-called top 30 stocks, and then rebalance either monthly or quarterly. I have no idea how well this will do, and it certainly wasn’t the methodology recommended in Greenblatt’s book. It also isn’t necessarily as tax-efficient, I suppose. Just some random ideas going forward.

Disclaimer: This post is a description of my own forays into investing, and should not be construed as investment advice or the recommendation of any particular security over any other. Please consult your investment adviser or accountant before making any investment decisions. What’s right for me is very likely to not be right for you.

Once again, there seems to be something lacking in my understanding of physics. I don’t think it’s possible to have a slide that goes backwards. Well, I suppose you could attach some kind of cable to the intended slider and pull them up the slide. That sounds like a blast for the kids in your life, I suppose. Still, the reverse slide I refer to today is instead the excellent performance of all the virtual portfolios this week. Okay, okay, some weren’t quite as excellent, but I promise there won’t be a shred of red in the first table.

Unfortunately for my desire to keep things simple, I did add new money to each of the portfolios this week, which means the basis has increased yet again. For those of you not keeping score at home, $1,350 has now been invested in each of the portfolios. We only have to go through this capital expansion process three more times, at which point I will simply let the portfolios ride on their own merits. (The process of switching stocks, and especially keeping the values roughly balanced, in the Magic Formula portfolio might prove interesting, but that’s a task for another day.) For now, let’s move right on to the data for the week:

Portfolio Last Week This Week % Chg Total Gain CAGR
Magic Formula $1574.36 $1788.36 +3.83% +$438.36 +54.64%
TMW $1419.58 $1638.76 +4.70% +$288.76 +45.72%
Precious Metals $1366.59 $1617.01 +7.19% +$267.10 +57.60%
Decision Moose $1323.15 $1580.26 +7.66% +$230.26 +28.63%
Caribou $1312.54 $1561.73 +7.17% +$211.73 +28.00%
Berkshire Hathaway $1326.08 $1485.26 +0.70% +$135.26 +10.36%

It’s only fitting that the top portfolio in this comparison is represented with green:

Portfolio Comparison: 2009-10-09

In short, it was a good week, especially for three of the portfolios. The pattern I’ve been observing recently has seemingly continued once again. I did look at a graph of the historical P/E ratio, and suddenly had a fit of pause as far as investing in stocks goes, but I suppose I’ll have to take what comes. None of the signals I currently pay attention to are particularly flashing cash as a good option, in any case. Here’s some brief detail about the portfolios:

  • First, the precious metals were up significantly. Silver more so than gold, but neither had a bad week by any stretch. Of course, the larger picture here is to examine what this data is telling us. Some of the deflationists out there, especially what I’ve been reading from Mish makes me start to lean toward the possibility of prolonged deflation, or at least spurts of inflation followed by deflation. The fact that gold is rising at the moment suggests inflation, but there are so many other factors in play when it comes to the price of gold that it’s difficult for me to say anything for sure. One thing I know is that consumer prices have not really been going up all that much (if at all) in the past year.
  • Despite being invested in entirely different regions of the world, both Decision Moose and Caribou had excellent weeks as well. They are making up some ground, but still have a sizable deficit to erode in order to end up near the top for the year. I do look forward to the year-end comparison.
  • Next in the list is TMW. Of course, with the market up on the week, this one is more or less a no-brainer. I’ll leave providing more interesting commentary as an exercise for the reader.
  • Strangely, the Magic Formula’s week, despite being good, was near the bottom of the barrel as far as this comparison goes. Of course, one stock in particular sure didn’t pull its weight this week, but more on that in the MFI detail section.
  • The true bottom of the barrel this week, however, was Berkshire Hathaway, which barely managed a gain at all, leaving it squarely in last place. Do I think that’s its ultimate fate? I have my concerns about whoever will replace Buffett, but I still think that it’s likely to beat the market over the next few years. Or at least, I’d hope so, especially as I consider investing some real money.

Not surprisingly, a week after switching from EPP back to EWZ, EPP had the better week. However, the difference was fairly minuscule, so I’m not going to let it frustrate me too much. The important lesson to learn here is that when attempting to time the market, especially in shorter time periods, you’re bound to lose now and then. The important thing with a strategy like this remains the long run. In any case, Caribou has no inkling of switching away from EWZ for the moment, with EWZ commanding a strong lead in the scoring.

Finally, here’s the MFI portfolio detail:

Stock Purchase Date Cost Last Week Current Dividends Gain
CTCM 2009-04-08 $5.80 $14.95 $17.60 $0.00 +203.45%
QLTI 2009-03-10 $1.44 $3.85 $3.81 $0.00 +164.58%
PRGX 2009-04-08 $3.25 $5.87 $5.99 $0.00 +84.31%
MSB 2009-03-10 $6.06 $10.00 $10.18 $0.38 +74.13%
CYTK 2009-09-09 $3.21 $4.85 $5.10 $0.00 +58.88%
HSII 2009-01-22 $16.79 $21.88 $23.80 $0.39 +44.12%
PTIE 2009-03-10 $3.96 $5.18 $5.55 $0.00 +40.15%
ENDP 2009-06-11 $17.59 $22.11 $23.82 $0.00 +35.42%
KSW 2009-01-22 $2.95 $3.92 $3.79 $0.10 +31.86%
VSNT 2009-05-07 $14.68 $16.89 $18.83 $0.00 +28.27%
CHKE 2009-05-07 $18.75 $21.78 $22.70 $1.00 +26.40%
QCOR 2009-05-07 $4.44 $5.39 $5.58 $0.00 +25.58%
ELNK 2009-04-08 $7.08 $8.47 $8.69 $0.14 +24.81%
SOLR 2009-07-10 $4.59 $5.28 $5.71 $0.00 +24.42%
GHM 2009-06-11 $13.95 $14.97 $16.00 $0.02 +14.84%
LO 2009-09-09 $73.49 $74.61 $77.79 $0.00 +5.85%
MTXX 2009-07-10 $5.37 $5.43 $5.66 $0.00 +5.40%
DIVX 2009-07-10 $5.02 $5.31 $5.27 $0.00 +4.98%
USMO 2009-08-05 $12.80 $12.51 $13.20 $0.00 +3.13%
EME 2009-08-05 $24.30 $23.94 $24.88 $0.00 +2.41%
GIGM 2009-10-07 $4.77 N/A $4.84 $0.00 +1.47%
KHD 2009-01-22 $10.17 $9.68 $10.25 $0.00 +0.80%
JCOM 2009-10-07 $22.18 N/A $22.02 $0.00 -0.71%
MIPS 2009-10-07 $4.15 N/A $4.09 $0.00 -1.45%
GNI 2009-08-05 $92.00 $91.00 $90.26 $0.00 -1.89%
PPD 2009-09-09 $47.50 $50.04 $42.09 $0.00 -11.38%
SCMP 2009-06-11 $6.43 $5.65 $5.27 $0.00 -18.04%

The big loser this week was PPD, down by an astounding 15.9%. After seeing that, I immediately checked on the cause. Apparently, the SEC may be inquiring into PPD somehow. I am unsure of the details and what it means for the future, but I suppose this is the risk with some MFI stocks. Is the price low because it’s a bargain, or is it low because there’s something wrong with the company I don’t know about? Then again, not knowing is half the fun. (Of course, if I knew I was going to just earn a consistent 50% return every year, I’d take that in a heartbeat. Wish me luck on that one.)

Disclaimer: This post is a description of my own forays into investing, and should not be construed as investment advice or the recommendation of any particular security over any other. Please consult your investment adviser or accountant before making any investment decisions. What’s right for me is very likely to not be right for you.

It’s now the ninth month during which I will be selecting stocks using the Magic Formula methodology. Starting in late January, I have been adding three stocks each month to the Magic Formula portfolio I include in my weekly comparison. It’s not quite the strategy Greenblatt suggested, as he recommended something like 6-8 stocks per quarter. In any case, I’ve chosen the monthly route for various reasons. (From a numbers standpoint, the best time to make selections might be right after the quarterly earnings reports, but that’s merely supposition, and since these reports are often delayed anyway, there may not be much advantage.)

At least for the moment, my methodology remains the same: pull the current list of top 30 stocks with a market capitalization of at least $50 million from theĀ  Magic Formula website, rank the list according to my own recreation of the formula, and then pick the top three that I don’t already own. It’s relatively simple, mechanical, and prevents me from having to make any emotional decisions. There is probably little advantage to this method rather than simply choosing a random set of three, but as a numbers person, this method appeals to me more. Your mileage may vary.

Anyway, of these top 30 stocks, I seem to already own 15 of them, so I have to move reasonably far down the list. (Nine of my current stocks have fallen off the list, mostly because their prices have risen to points where they’re no longer such a bargain.) Here are my three selections for this month:

MIPS Technologies Inc. (MIPS)

  • Price: $3.96
  • Market Cap: $178.517M
  • Enterprise Value: $155.666M
  • Earnings Yield: 13.807%
  • Return on Invested Capital: 824.080%

The MIPS name will be familiar to many of you in the computer field, as the producer of both embedded processors and instruction set architectures used both in commercial applications (their processors) as well as in education, teaching programming students assembly language. Chances are, you’ve used something that’s been touched by MIPS, as their processors are used in numerous devices, including DVD players, televisions, laser printers, and video game consoles, including the Playstation 2. After making an IPO in 1998, MIPS became yet another darling of the dot com era, before ultimately declining after the bust. The stock performance over the last five years has been none too impressive, with a persistent, if unsteady decline. There does not appear to be a dividend, so I have my doubts about the future performance of this stock.

GigaMedia Ltd. (GIGM)

  • Price: $4.83
  • Market Cap: $262.583M
  • Enterprise Value: $206.559M
  • Earnings Yield: 15.520%
  • Return on Invested Capital: 236.775%

Another technology company in what is looking like a round of technology stocks, GIGM provides software and services for various online games, especially in Asia. Looking at the price history, it suffered a catastrophic decline after the dot com bust, but began to show a trend of strong growth in 2006. The trend did start reversing toward the end of 2007, and the current trend appears to be one of neutrality. While they paid a dividend once before, there is no evidence that this is continuing.

j2 Global Communications, Inc. (JCOM)

  • Price: $22.19
  • Market Cap: $999.926M
  • Enterprise Value: $812.812M
  • Earnings Yield: 12.881%
  • Return on Invested Capital: 632.590%

JCOM offers messaging and other communications services, such as voicemail, e-mail, and call handling around the globe. Barring a decline in 1999-2000, JCOM otherwise shows signs of steady growth. This growth has been somewhat interrupted since late 2007, but how much of that has do with the company itself and how much is resulting from the recent deflation, I have no idea. In any case, there is a rough trend of rising prices so far this year. Unfortunately, this stock also pays no dividend, so any income will have to come from capital gains.

In a nice change of pace, there were no pharmaceutical companies this time around. Of course, instead, I ended up with three technology companies. On the other hand, it isn’t 2000 anymore, so I’m not particularly concerned. These stocks should be added to the virtual portfolio sometime tomorrow, as well as $150 being added to each of the other portfolios.

Disclaimer: This post is a description of my own forays into investing, and should not be construed as investment advice or the recommendation of any particular security over any other. Please consult your investment adviser or accountant before making any investment decisions. What’s right for me is very likely to not be right for you.

Next Page »